Blog/How to win back a contractor who moved to another supplier

How to win back a contractor who moved to another supplier

Nov 209 min read

Find out why a contractor left, decide if they are worth chasing, ask for one job and match your offer to the reason they left. A guide for LBM dealers.

Sales Strategy
How to win back a contractor who moved to another supplier

To win back a contractor who moved their business to another supplier, start by confirming the account is still active somewhere else and finding out why it left. Then decide whether it is worth a real effort, wait for or create a specific opening, and ask for one job rather than the whole account. Match what you offer to the reason the customer left, treat the first order as a trial, and set a date to stop if nothing changes.

This guide is for outside and inside reps, sales managers and owners at lumber yards and multi-category dealers, drywall and insulation dealers, window and door dealers, and hardware stores with pro accounts. It covers accounts that have clearly gone to a competitor. If you are still trying to spot customers who are buying less, start with how to recover lost revenue from inactive accounts. If the business left with a sales rep who resigned, see what to do when a sales rep leaves for a competitor.

Confirm the account is gone, and why

A contractor who stopped buying has not always switched suppliers. Some close, retire, move out of your area or stop doing the kind of work you supply. Before anyone spends time on a win-back, check three things:

  • Purchase history. When was the last order, which categories did the account buy, and how do the last 12 months compare with the 12 before? A contractor who still buys a few fill-in items has a different story from one who has bought nothing.
  • Current work. If the contractor is still pulling permits in your market and your orders are near zero, the work is going somewhere else.
  • What your team already knows. Read the account notes, lost quotes and any open issues. Ask the rep who owned it what happened, and write the answer down.

Then put the reason in a plain category: price, service, a relationship with the rep, product or brand availability, or a competitor's package offer. Be honest about it. If the real reason was a string of late deliveries, calling it price will send you back with the wrong offer.

When the reason is unclear, ask the customer. One respondent to an LBM Journal reader survey on competing with a large new entrant put it simply: "Ask customers that you've lost why they switched." Brand availability is worth checking too. In 2015 contractor research summarized by Principia, more than 70% of contractors and installers said they would buy from another dealer if their preferred brands were not available from their primary dealer. That research was about windows and patio doors, but it is a reminder that a missing line can move an account without anyone complaining.

Decide which lost accounts deserve a real effort

You cannot chase every former customer, and some should not be chased. Research from outside building materials gives a useful starting point. In a study of lost customers at a large national telecommunications firm, V. Kumar, Yashoda Bhagwat and Xi Zhang found that customers with a stronger first relationship were more likely to accept a win-back offer. In the authors' summary of the findings, customers who left for a better deal were more likely to come back than those who left over poor service, and those who left for both reasons were the least likely to return. Phone subscribers are not contractors, so treat this as a prompt for your own judgment, not a rule.

For each lost account, look at:

  1. What it used to be worth. Past annual purchases and how many categories it bought. A contractor who bought framing, windows and trim is a bigger prize than a single-category buyer.
  2. How deep the relationship was. How long they bought, how many people at the contractor knew your team, and whether they ever sent you referrals.
  3. Whether they have work now. Active permits and job addresses in your area.
  4. Whether the reason is fixable. A brand you now carry or a rep you have since changed is a good reason to call. A disagreement over credit terms that has not changed is a reason to leave it with your credit team.

Sort the list into three groups: pursue now, watch for an opening, and let go. Write down why each account landed where it did, so the next review starts from facts instead of memory.

Wait for an opening, or make one

A win-back call works best when something has changed. Common openings include:

  • The competitor's service slips. In the same LBM Journal survey, one dealer said customers who had moved to a big competitor "were quick to come back after 4 or 5 months because their customer service was non-existent." Another said they "stayed in contact, didn't burn any bridges" and won some business back.
  • The competitor is short on stock. In an LBM Journal Tough Call scenario about rebuilding trust, a custom builder reopens an account only because his regular supplier is sold out of key materials.
  • A new job appears. A permit for a project that fits your strengths gives you a reason to call about that job.
  • Someone new is buying. A new estimator, purchasing manager or project manager at the contractor may not share the old grudge.
  • A competitor's special deal runs its course. In a November 2026 Tough Call scenario, a longtime builder customer takes a free roofing offer on its next four homes from a competitor recently bought by a consolidator, and tells the dealer, "Now we'll see if they can deliver on service." One of the options the scenario offers is to hold the line and be ready when the service slips.

The Tough Call stories are illustrative scenarios written for readers to discuss, not reports of real dealers. They still describe moments most reps will recognize.

Between openings, keep in touch lightly. A short note about a product they used to buy, a check-in when you see a new permit, or a holiday visit keeps the door open without pressure.

Open with a listening meeting and one job

The first conversation should be about the customer, not your pitch. Among the options in the Rebuilding trust scenario, two fit most win-backs: meet former customers individually with the goal "not to sell, but to listen and learn," and ask them directly what it would take to give you another chance.

Decide who goes. If the problem was the relationship with one rep, send someone else. Dealers who answered an LBM Journal question about inactive accounts made the same point. As one put it, "sometimes the representative assigned to a customer might not get along with them," so "let the next representative give it a shot." A sales manager or GM joining the first visit also shows the customer you take it seriously.

In the meeting:

  • If your dealer let them down, say so plainly and do not argue about the details.
  • Explain what has changed only if it really has changed, such as a new person on the account or a line you now carry.
  • Ask about their next two or three jobs.
  • Ask for one specific quote: one package on one job. A drywall dealer might ask for the board and insulation on a single house. A hardware store might ask to supply fasteners and fill-in items for one remodel. Winning one job is a smaller decision for the contractor than moving the whole account.

Log what you learned, the job you asked about and the date you agreed to follow up.

Match the offer to the reason they left

What you offer should answer the reason the customer gave you. The telecom study also tested different win-back offers. The authors report that a bundled offer of a discount plus an upgrade brought back the most customers, but those customers left again soonest and spent the least. A service upgrade won back the fewest, and those customers stayed the longest and spent the most.

For a building materials dealer, that suggests:

  • Left over price. Quote the specific job sharply and show the whole picture, such as what is included and how the package compares, instead of cutting the account's price level across the board. If they later want better account pricing, use the same give-and-get thinking as in when to give a contractor better pricing.
  • Left over service. Make a specific promise for the first job that you know you can keep, and name the person responsible. Do not promise more than your yard can deliver.
  • Left over a person. Introduce the new account owner and keep the manager involved for the first few jobs.
  • Left over a brand or product. If you now carry the line, say so and quote it. If you do not, be honest and focus on the categories where you can help.

Treat the first order as a trial

The first order back is when the contractor decides whether you have really changed. The rep or manager should check that the order went as promised and call the contractor after delivery to ask how it went. If it went well, ask for the next package on the same job or the next job.

Then watch the account. Review purchases by category every month for the next six months. A customer who returns for one cheap order and disappears again is a different result from one who starts buying a second category.

Set a rule for when to stop

Win-back lists grow stale if nobody reviews them. Dealers in the LBM Journal inactive-accounts responses described different rules: one gives the assigned rep an action plan once a customer has been inactive for more than six months and reassigns the account if that fails. Another suggested giving reps three months to generate revenue before management reassigns their accounts. A third said the first step is to find out why dead accounts are still on the books, starting with the question "Is the buying done from somewhere else?"

Pick a rule that fits your market. Review the pursue and watch lists each quarter, move accounts between groups as their situation changes, and record the result: won back, partly won back, still watching or let go. Over time, those records show which reasons for leaving your team actually recovers from.

An illustrative example

A drywall and insulation dealer reviews its contractor accounts and finds a drywall contractor that used to be one of its steady board and insulation buyers and has bought nothing in the last nine months. The contractor is still pulling permits in the dealer's area. The old account notes mention two late deliveries on a big job and a heated call with the rep at the time.

The sales manager and a different rep ask for a short meeting. They do not pitch. They ask what happened and listen. The contractor says the new supplier's pricing is fine but its deliveries have started to run late. The manager says the dealer let him down before and asks to quote the board and insulation for one house starting next month, with the manager as the contact for that order. The contractor agrees to compare the quote. The dealer wins that house, the manager calls after delivery, and the rep asks about the next house. The account stays on the monthly review list for six months.

This is a made-up example to show the steps. It is not a SalesJack customer result.

Where connected data helps

Win-backs depend on finding the right former customers and knowing what they bought and why they left. SalesJack connects ERP sales data, permits, quotes and CRM records for building materials suppliers. With SalesJack Radar, reps and managers can ask questions such as "Which of my customers have active permits but no recent orders?" and get answers from connected ERP, quote, permit and CRM data. SalesJack's analytics dashboards show where customers are buying less, and by matching ERP and permit data they can show what share of a customer's material spend you are getting. Reps log conversations, assignments and reminders against each account, and dealers can build email and text lists from ERP data to re-engage accounts. What it can show depends on what your ERP and CRM records contain.

If you want to see it on your own data, you can book a demo.

Sources