
How manufacturer reps can decide which dealers get a showroom display
Choose which dealers get a showroom display, tie each one to a dealer sales plan and check whether it turns into quotes and orders. A guide for manufacturer reps.
How building materials reps decide on a contractor's price level: check what the account buys, name the business you want in return, and review the results.

Give a contractor a better price level only when you can name the business you expect in return and can check later whether it arrived. Start with what the account buys from you now, by category, and what it likely buys elsewhere. Then choose one of three answers: a better level tied to a specific commitment, a sharper price on one job package, or no change yet with a clear explanation of what would qualify. Put the request in writing to whoever sets price levels, and set a date to compare the account's purchases with what was agreed.
Most dealers already price contractors differently. In a 2014 LBM Journal survey that drew 259 dealer responses, readers described pricing tailored to volume, product mix, distance to jobsites, payment history and ease of doing business, and some described three or four price levels running from walk-in customers to their best accounts. The hard moment comes when a contractor asks to move up, or when a rep thinks a better level would win more of the account. This guide is for outside and inside reps, and the sales managers who approve their requests, at lumber yards and multi-category dealers, specialty window, door, roofing and siding dealers, drywall and insulation suppliers, and hardware stores with pro desks.
Before you discuss pricing with a customer, find out what your company lets you offer. Dealers differ widely. In an LBM Journal survey published in January 2020, 57% of responding companies let salespeople adjust prices within a set range before approval, 17% gave them free rein and 26% allowed no adjustment without approval. One respondent said any reduction beyond 10%, or on a list of specific products, needs the owner's approval. Another summed up his rule this way: "If I give up something, I have to get something in return." He added that a price concession usually comes while upgrading the sale or increasing the size of the order.
Learn three things before the conversation:
The last point can surprise a rep. One dealer in the 2014 survey said it keeps the items with the greatest pricing pressure at the same competitive price regardless of customer type. A better level may not touch those items at all. Keep payment terms out of it too. Terms belong with your credit team, and at least one dealer in that survey said it generally offers discounted pricing or payment terms, not both.
Pull the contractor's purchases for the last 12 months and break them out by product category. Look for:
The last two matter most. A contractor who buys commodity framing items only when you are cheapest may be asking for a better level on the very products where your margin is thinnest. In a 2023 LBM Journal survey on big box commodity pricing, one dealer said that when a contractor gets a reputation for cherry picking, it starts quoting lump sum or explains that the quote is "all or none." An earlier 2015 survey found that 88.4% of responding lumberyards put item prices and quantities on their quotes, and many respondents tied their package price to the customer buying the whole list.
A price request is an opening to ask about the rest of the contractor's business. Compare the jobs the contractor is building with the orders you received. Permits, job addresses and your own conversations all help. If a builder pulled permits for several houses last year and you supplied framing on only some of them, you know where the room is.
Look across categories as well. A framing customer who never buys windows, doors or trim from you may be buying them from a specialty dealer. A drywall contractor who buys board but not insulation or steel framing may be splitting suppliers. Treat each gap as a question to raise with the contractor. Our guide to winning jobs your builders buy elsewhere covers how to ask.
1. A better level, tied to a commitment. Use this when the account already buys a meaningful share from you and you can name the added business: a category they buy elsewhere, a set of upcoming jobs, or the whole package instead of selected items. Choose a commitment you can later see in your own records.
2. A sharper price on one package. Use this when the request comes from one competitive job. Price that job through your normal quote approval and leave the account's level alone. A job price ends with the job. A level change applies to everything the account buys, including what it already buys from you at today's price. For a single quote objection, see what to do when a contractor says your lumber quote is too expensive.
3. No change yet. Use this when purchases are small or falling and you cannot name the added business. Explain what would qualify under your company's rules, such as buying a category through you for a period before the next review. A clear "not yet, and here is how" keeps the account talking to you.
A better level costs money from the first order, on every purchase the contractor already makes from you. The new business has to cover that before the change pays off. Work it out before you ask:
John Wagner, writing in LBM Journal in 2019, warned that heavy discounting at the top of a customer list is easy to miss without a data-driven look. He suggested finding the point where further discounting stops making sense, and checking gross margin for your top 25 or 50 customers. He also noted that some large customers genuinely cost less to serve. Include service costs you actually know about, such as delivery patterns, and leave out the ones you would be guessing at.
Give the person who sets levels one short page:
A request in this form can be approved or turned down on facts. It also leaves a record for whoever reviews the account next.
Bill Lee suggests a test question for a buyer who says your price is too high: "Are you telling me that if our price was identical to our competitor's price that we could do business?" In his 2024 LBM Journal column, he also recommends negotiation training for any sales team with pricing authority. The same test fits a price-level request. Ask what would change if the level changed. Which jobs would come to you? Which categories? Who at the company decides those purchases?
Then make the commitment specific. "We can move you to our builder level on lumber and panels if the windows and doors for your next houses in that subdivision come through us" is something both sides can check. "We'll take care of you" is not. Consultant Shane Soule described offering to cover a customer's print costs if they committed all of their business to him. Whatever you offer, get your company's approval first.
Record the agreement with the account: the level, the categories or jobs, who agreed, and the review date. Set a reminder so the review actually happens.
Look at the account each month for the first few months. Are orders arriving in the categories you named? Did the jobs the contractor mentioned come to you? Are you now asked to quote the whole package, or still only the commodity items?
At the review date, compare purchases with what was agreed. If the business came, keep the level. If some of it came, talk to the contractor before deciding anything, because a job may simply have been delayed. If nothing changed, go back to your company's rules. In LBM Journal's 2018 survey on contractor discounts, one dealer described contractor pricing levels based on purchasing volume and reviewed annually. Whatever the review finds, tell the contractor what it showed and what happens next rather than letting the price change quietly.
Each step above depends on seeing an account's purchases, quotes and jobs together. SalesJack works across connected ERP, quote, permit and CRM data. Its Analytics maps product classes into key categories, and where permit data is matched to ERP data, shows what percentage of each customer's material spend you are getting and which addresses you are not winning. Before a pricing conversation, a rep can ask Radar a question such as "What has this builder purchased across its jobsites?" The agreed follow-up and review date can sit with the account in the CRM as an assignment and reminder. Price levels and approvals stay with your company's own rules and people. To see how this would look with your data, book a demo.

Choose which dealers get a showroom display, tie each one to a dealer sales plan and check whether it turns into quotes and orders. A guide for manufacturer reps.

A practical guide for lumber yards and dealers: which association members to pursue, who should attend, and how to turn meetings into quotes.

When a sales rep leaves for a competitor, sort their accounts by open work and risk, call about real jobs, protect open quotes and check purchases weekly.