
How to win back a contractor who moved to another supplier
Find out why a contractor left, decide if they are worth chasing, ask for one job and match your offer to the reason they left. A guide for LBM dealers.
How dealers can decide whether one rep should hunt new accounts, which accounts go on that list, and when a won account moves to an account rep.

A dedicated new-business rep makes sense when your outside reps are closing too few first orders, good prospects and permit leads sit unworked, and the cause is a lack of selling time or focus rather than a lack of leads. Before you hire or reassign anyone, check last year's first orders by rep, write down exactly which accounts the new-business rep may pursue, and agree when a new account moves to an account rep. Skip those three decisions and the new role tends to start arguments over who owns which customer.
This guide is for sales managers, GMs and owners at multi-category dealers, lumber yards, drywall and insulation dealers and hardware stores with pro accounts. Manufacturers selling through dealers face a different version of this question, because their "new accounts" are dealers, so they are left out here.
Most dealer outside reps are asked to do two jobs at once: find new contractors and grow the ones they already have. Recruiter Rikka Brandon described the two types in LBM Journal. Hunters are "always cold-calling, dropping in on jobsites." Farmers "can take a $10K account to a $1 million account if the business is there." She also warned that "well-established businesses often need a farmer, but they think they need a hunter."
When LBM Journal asked dealers in September 2026 whether salespeople should only sell, the answers split. One dealer wrote, "Specialization is where your growth comes from. Salespeople need to be out there getting NEW business." Another said outside sales "should concentrate on generating new business and retaining current business." A third offered advice worth following before any change: "Measure where the hours actually go before you reorganize."
Research points both ways too. A study of 357 salespeople at one large business-to-business firm found that reps strong at both hunting and farming earned higher profits when they were also customer oriented (DeCarlo and Lam, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science). The lead author cautioned that it covered one company in one industry. A later study found those same do-both reps report more stress, and that the stress grows when they also carry non-selling service work under results-only management (McClure, DeCarlo and Hansen, Industrial Marketing Management; plain-language summary). Neither study is about building materials, so use them as a reason to check your own numbers.
The decision should come from your own sales history. Pull these for each outside rep over the last 12 months:
Look for the pattern across these numbers. If reps close plenty of first orders but those accounts rarely order again, you have a growth problem, and a hunter will make it worse. If existing accounts are growing but first orders are rare and leads go untouched, new business is the gap. If every number is weak and reps spend much of the week on non-selling work, fix that with support before you add a sales role.
Our guide to setting new-business targets explains how to work out how much new business each rep needs once you count lost customers. Use that number here: if the team cannot reach it with current time and focus, the structure question is real.
There are three common answers, and each fits a different situation.
Keep generalists and protect prospecting time. Every outside rep still owns new and existing accounts, but the sales manager blocks time for new-business calls and checks it weekly. This suits smaller dealers, markets where the same builders keep coming back and teams where each rep already has a manageable list. It fails when service work keeps eating the protected time.
Add a dedicated new-business rep. One person pursues prospects and hands won accounts to account reps. This suits dealers entering new areas or customer types, or teams where the account reps are strong relationship managers who rarely open new doors. It costs a salary before it produces orders, and it only works if the handoff rules below are clear.
Free up selling time first. Move takeoffs, order chasing and paperwork to estimators or a sales assistant, then revisit the question. Several dealers in the LBM Journal discussion described this route. One added a sales assistant "to handle administrative work, paperwork, and support tasks so the sales team can stay in front of customers." Another advised that a phased, reversible change "beats a big-bang reorganization every time."
A new-business rep needs a defined list, or the role turns into a fight over the best prospects in someone else's territory. Wilson Lumber's posting for a business development representative in Tennessee shows one dealer's version. The role builds a target list of builders, remodelers and contractors, focuses on "Prospect accounts and high-upside Bronze accounts," and works with account managers "to develop pursuit plans." It is one company's job description, but it shows the kind of boundary to set.
A workable list usually includes:
Everything else stays with the account rep. When a permit lead or inquiry comes in, check first whether the company already buys from you. If it does, it goes to the rep who owns that account, even if the job looks like new business. Our guide to assigning new leads covers the routing rules in more detail.
Pick the handoff point before the first account is won. Common choices are after the first order ships, after the second order, or after the account has bought for a set period. Earlier handoffs free the new-business rep sooner. Later ones protect a fragile relationship. Whichever you choose, apply it the same way every time.
Treat the handoff as a sales call. The new-business rep introduces the account rep in person or on a joint call, about a real job or open quote. Any open quotes move with the account, with their next step and date written down. The account rep confirms what the customer bought, what it still buys elsewhere and the next package worth pursuing. Never move an account in the middle of a quote decision.
Credit matters too. DeCarlo and Lam found that pay plans built around winning new customers can push salespeople toward hunting. If the new-business rep is paid only for first orders, expect plenty of first orders and less attention to whether they repeat. One option is to give that rep some credit for the account's early repeat business, so both reps care about the same customer. Set the details with whoever owns compensation at your company.
Give any change at least two quarters before you judge it. Each month, look at:
If first orders rise but repeat orders do not, fix the handoff before you add another hunter. If neither moves, look again at the target list and at whether the leads were ever good enough.
A lumber yard with a handful of outside reps reviews last year and finds that most first orders came from one rep. Permit leads for builders who had never bought from the yard often sat unworked, while existing accounts kept growing. The owner moves that rep into a new-business role with a written list: permit-active builders with no purchase history and lapsed accounts no one is calling. The rep keeps a new account through its second order, then introduces the territory rep at the next job. At the monthly review, the sales manager checks second orders as closely as first orders.
This is a scenario, not a customer result.
The structure decision is yours, but it depends on knowing who already buys from you. SalesJack's CRM for building materials dealers connects to permit databases such as Construction Monitor, filters permits by project type and region, and matches them to existing customers and addresses. Leads from existing customers can be assigned to their reps, while new leads go to the sales manager for assignment. That maps directly onto a split between account reps and a new-business rep. SalesJack Radar lets a manager ask questions such as "Which of my customers have active permits but no recent orders?" and see flagged opportunities across the team, while each rep sees a prioritized view of their own accounts.
It does not decide your handoff point or pay plan. If you want to see how it would work with your ERP and permit data, you can book a demo.
A dedicated new-business rep is a fixed cost, and a small dealer may get more from freeing existing reps' time. The research cited here comes from other industries and, in one case, a single company. Customers who liked the rep who won their business may resist moving to someone else, so plan introductions with care.

Find out why a contractor left, decide if they are worth chasing, ask for one job and match your offer to the reason they left. A guide for LBM dealers.

When a dealer buys less from you, find out whether it is inventory, a new buying route, slower local demand or a competing product before you respond.

As new-home lumber demand falls, decide how much sales time to give pro remodelers, which ones to call first and how to win their job-by-job orders.